Frequently asked questions about the calculations, the labels and the data behind them
Through our carbon emissions assessment work with hotels and restaurants internationally, TLC identified that food and beverage operations were one of the largest contributors to hospitality emissions (excluding guest travel). This was particularly evident in EU, UK and American venues where beef dishes such as burgers and steaks were on the menu.
While F&B typically contributes 30% of revenue for hotels, it was producing up to 50% of their on-site emissions.
Adjusting menu options and portion sizes for high-emission foods such as beef is one of the quickest and most significant ways to reduce carbon emissions in hospitality.
While reducing carbon is important, we also recognised that food production in high-biodiversity areas damages local freshwater resources and ecosystems. Our Environmental Impact Calculator raises awareness of these wider environmental impacts, encouraging venues to look beyond just carbon when addressing sustainability.
CHEF uses the impact method behind the European Union's Product Environmental Footprint (PEF), known as EF 3.1, with average life cycle data from Agribalyse. This estimates a dish's impacts from farm to plate across 16 environmental indicators, covering climate, air, water, land, resources and human health. It is not a verified PEF study. Every dish rating in CHEF now uses all 16 indicators, combined with the EU's own weighting. To keep the results easy to use, we summarise them as one A–E grade and four positions that chefs can talk about: Climate, Land, Water, and Energy and resources. Tapping the i button on a position shows the indicators behind it, and the Pro certificate reports all 16 indicators in full.
The answer to that is a wholehearted yes! But let's consider what may be driving those choices. For example, based on a review of the science literature we know that beef is eaten more and in larger amounts in hospitality venues than in the guests own home, so dining out is seen as an opportunity to indulge.
However, there are indulgent choices that are less environmentally impactful that can be made, and at the same time provide the premium pricing that often drives hospitality venues to profile steaks or burgers.
A restaurant we worked with identified that a seafood burger containing mixed fish, prawn, crab and lobster, hit the luxury indulgence spot just right, while also delivering the premium price wanted by the venue. Emissions down, prices slightly up, and diners feeling they had come to a really classy venue. Over a short time there was substantial increase in the seafood burger menu choice by diners
An easy to understand environment impact label next to the dish also nudges guest towards less impactful options (this is clear in research and real world F&B operations) and provides the buzz of doing good while indulging. So no it doesn't and shouldn't have to be a form of hair-shirt sustainability abstinence, people enjoy eating out and small changes such as reducing the high impact foods portion size, mixing exciting additional ingredients, plate layout, or tasty alternatives can deliver great choices. As one of our client chefs told us:
"Chefs really care about the environment because good quality dining comes from sourcing excellent ingredients with great texture and taste. Poor environments and conditions creates bland food. A good chef rises to the challenges and enjoys the creativity needed to deliver a truly engaging dining experience that also takes better care of nature." ---- (Chef Monty, Sahana Restaurant and Bar)
CHEF uses all 16 indicators from the EU Environmental Footprint method (EF 3.1), taken from the Agribalyse 3.2 database. These feed the overall A–E dish grade. So that the results are easy to explain to colleagues and guests, we also group them into four positions:
| Position | What it covers | PEF indicators included | EU weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| Climate | Greenhouse gas emissions, shown in kg CO₂e per serving | Climate change | 21.1% |
| Land | Pressure on soils and land habitats: farmland use and the nitrogen pollution that settles on it | Land use; acidification; terrestrial eutrophication | 17.9% |
| Water | Pressure on rivers, lakes and seas: water scarcity, nutrient pollution and toxic run-off | Water use (scarcity); freshwater eutrophication; marine eutrophication; freshwater ecotoxicity | 16.2% |
| Energy and resources | Energy, materials and air pollution | Fossil and mineral resource use; ionising radiation; particulate matter; photochemical ozone; ozone depletion; human toxicity (cancer and non-cancer) | 44.9% |
The remaining eight indicators (fossil energy, minerals and metals, ionising radiation, fine particulates, photochemical smog, ozone depletion and human toxicity) make up the fourth position, Energy and resources (44.9% of the EU weighting). Its card shows what mainly drives it:
Energy and resources rarely changes a dish's grade on its own, because it mostly follows the same ingredients as Climate and Land. Its value is in showing the next thing to improve once a dish is already low in meat. CHEF Pro also lists all 16 indicators together, grouped under the four positions, with each one's share of the dish's score.
Agribalyse models French electricity, which is mostly nuclear. Ionising radiation is therefore higher, and fossil energy lower, than they would be for a UK kitchen. Grouping both in one position reduces the effect of this.
Each position shows its A–E grade and the ingredient causing most of it. Climate also shows kg CO₂e per serving. Land, Water, and Energy and resources each combine several indicators measured in different units, so the grade is the headline. Tap the i button to see each indicator for your dish, such as water use in m³ or marine eutrophication in kg N-eq, with its share of that position.
In the recipe table, each ingredient has a coloured dot for Climate, Land, Water and Energy & resources. The colours work like the traffic lights on a nutrition label: they show the ingredient's impact per kg, compared with around 2,100 raw ingredients. Green is the lower half, amber the middle, and red the highest 10%. The Impact share column shows how much of the dish's overall environmental impact (not its weight) comes from each ingredient. So a small amount of beef shows red dots with a small share: an intensive ingredient that only adds a little here. On phones the share column is hidden to keep the table simple. Click a dot to see its figures per kg and what it adds to the dish. The A–E letters are kept for the dish as a whole.
Square metres measure how much land is used, but not what happens to it. Under the PEF method, land use is measured with a soil quality index in points (Pt). It combines how much land is used, for how long, and how much the use degrades the soil: its fertility, its ability to absorb water, its resistance to erosion and its ability to filter pollutants.
Intensive farming on poor soil, or clearing natural land for crops or pasture, scores much higher than the same area of well-managed land. In this way the indicator reflects the damage done, not just the space taken up.
The PEF land-use indicator measures soil quality. It does not count species directly. That's why the CHEF Land position also includes acidification and terrestrial eutrophication: nitrogen and ammonia pollution from fertilisers and manure are among the main drivers of plant and habitat loss on land.
Comparing Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) impact results from different sources is complex due to several factors that can lead to variations:
Always refer to source documentation for a comprehensive understanding of LCA methodologies. This public app uses the Agribalyse Life Cycle Assessment database from France. For beef and lamb, where origin matters most, you can choose where the meat comes from (see the next question).
Yes. Agribalyse data are French, and for most ingredients the difference between countries is small next to the difference between foods. Beef and lamb are the exception: how and where the animals are farmed can change their climate footprint several times over.
Plain beef and lamb cuts in the recipe table therefore have a Select source menu. Until you choose, the French figures are used.
Each origin adjusts the climate figure only, using a ratio from published regional studies (listed in the methodology, section 2.5). The other indicators stay as they are. The source you choose is saved with the recipe and appears on labels and the Pro certificate, for example “Beef mince (Brazil)”.
What about shrimp? Farmed shrimp varies hugely, and the biggest factor is whether the pond was dug in cleared mangrove forest, which the country of origin doesn't tell you. Shrimp rows show a note instead of a source menu; ask your supplier about certification and mangrove-free farming.
The dish rating is built on the EU's Environmental Footprint impact method (EF 3.1), the method behind the PEF and the single score published in the French Agribalyse database. The EU method gives the single score; the A–E grade boundaries are CHEF's own. The calculation has four steps:
The average person's total footprint is 1,000 mPt a year, or about 2.7 mPt a day. Food is the largest part of that: 46% of the environmental footprint of consumption in the EU, measured with the same 16 indicators and EU weighting (European Environment Agency, Consumption footprint indicator, 2023 data, built on the EU Joint Research Centre's Consumption Footprint). That gives food about 1.26 mPt per person per day. If a main meal is about a third of a day's food, its fair share is about 0.4 mPt (1.26 ÷ 3 = 0.42).
In CHEF this benchmark is shown as "an average meal": the impact of an average person's main meal today. A dish shown as "2.3× an average meal" has 2.3 times that impact; "20% of an average meal" has a fifth of it.
Note: food's 46% share comes from EU consumption data, while the per-person reference (1,000 mPt a year) is the EF method's global average. Combining the two is an approximation. An average EU citizen's footprint is higher than the global average, so the fair share used here is slightly stricter than one based on EU footprints alone.
That average meal sets the boundary between grades C and D. Each grade below it halves the impact, and each grade above it doubles the impact:
| Grade | EF single score per serving | Compared with an average meal | Typical dishes |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 0.10 mPt or less | a quarter or less | Lentil, bean, tofu and vegetable dishes |
| B | 0.10 – 0.20 mPt | a quarter to a half | Salmon, pork, chickpea curry |
| C | 0.20 – 0.40 mPt | a half to the same | Most chicken and duck dishes |
| D | 0.40 – 0.80 mPt | up to double | Beef burger, bolognese and roast, lamb burger, Full English, farmed prawns |
| E | above 0.80 mPt | more than double | Lamb tagine, mutton hotpot, goat stew, large ribeye steak |
The average footprint today is already too high: the European Environment Agency reports that EU consumption exceeded its fair share of planetary boundaries for five of the impact categories in 2024 (same source). So a dish graded B or better is consistent with a sustainable diet, a C is about today's average, and D or E is above it.
Grades rise in doubling steps because food impacts span a very wide range: a lamb dish can have 20 to 40 times the impact of a lentil dish. With equal-sized steps, every plant-based dish would be crowded into A and all the heaviest dishes would share the same E. With doubling steps, moving up one grade always means halving the dish's footprint.
Each position is graded on the same scale, using that position's share of the EU weighting. For example, Climate carries 21.1% of the weight, so the Climate boundaries are 21.1% of the overall ones. In kg CO₂e per serving, that gives Climate A up to 0.75, B up to 1.5, C up to 3.0 and D up to 6.0, with E above. A dish graded "Climate B, Land C, Water B" is therefore being compared with the same average meal in each area.
Food production is responsible for approximately 26% of global greenhouse gas emissions. The way we grow, process, transport, and consume food has a significant impact on our planet's climate.
Our calculations follow the EU Environmental Footprint (PEF) method and use Agribalyse life cycle data, which is built on ISO 14040/14044 life cycle assessment standards. Water is assessed as water scarcity, the measure used by the PEF method.
Yes, about 140 organic foods, including organic beef, lamb, pork, chicken, dairy, pasta, and some vegetables and fruits. In the recipe table, any ingredient that has an organic version shows a Conventional · try organic button: click it to swap in the organic version at the same weight and see the effect on your dish straight away. For beef and lamb, choose Organic in the row's Select source menu. You can also search with the word “organic” (for example “organic carrots”).
Each organic food is built from the conventional food by adjusting its farming stage, indicator by indicator, by Agribalyse's organic-to-conventional farm figures for the same commodity. Processing, packaging, transport and cooking stay as they are, so organic and conventional foods cover the same life cycle and can be compared directly.
Organic farming usually shows much lower ecotoxicity but uses more land, and its climate footprint per kg is often similar or a little higher. There is a lot of variation in how organic products are produced, and the data are French national averages. The EF method also measures land per kg of food and gives little credit for biodiversity or soil health, where organic farming tends to do best, so many researchers think it undersells organic.
Is organic healthier? Large reviews find organic crops carry far fewer pesticide residues and somewhat more antioxidants, and organic milk and meat more omega-3 fats. A clear benefit to people's health has not been proven, partly because people who buy organic tend to have healthier lifestyles anyway. CHEF uses the same nutrient data for organic and conventional foods (except chicken), because the national food composition table doesn't separate them.
Every CHEF dish rating uses all 16 indicators recommended by the EU Product Environmental Footprint method. The Pro certificate also reports each indicator separately, broken down by ingredient:
The results follow the PEF method and the Agribalyse 3.2 database. They are indicative, and are not a verified PEF study of your own supply chain.
Our platform provides comprehensive nutritional analysis alongside environmental data, allowing chefs, nutritionists, and hospitality managers to optimise menus for both planetary health and human health. The full database covers 60+ indicators:
CHEF's A–E grades are calculated by CHEF. They use the EU's EF 3.1 impact method and average data, but the grade boundaries are CHEF's own. The EU has not issued or endorsed them, and they are not certified by an independent body.
Guests in the EU. Since 27 September 2026, Directive (EU) 2024/825 prohibits sustainability labels shown to consumers unless they are based on a third-party certification scheme or established by a public authority. It also prohibits generic claims such as "eco-friendly" without recognised excellent environmental performance. The Commission's Q&A (September 2026) does not address calculated dish grades, so whether an A–E badge counts as such a label is unsettled. Until this is clearer, we suggest that venues serving EU guests leave the A–E badge off guest menus and show specific figures with their source instead, for example: "About 1.2 kg CO₂e per serving, from average data (Agribalyse 3.2, EF 3.1)".
Guests in the UK. The Directive does not apply to UK-only marketing, but the CMA's Green Claims Code does. Claims must be accurate, clear and backed by evidence, and must not leave out important information. If you show a grade, explain what it measures and that it uses average data.
Business use. These EU rules cover marketing to consumers. Kitchen decisions, teaching, tenders and client reports are outside them, although other advertising rules can apply and individual countries can extend protection to businesses. Figures from a sustainability report come back into scope if you reuse them in consumer marketing.
Is PEF required by law? Not for food. PEF is a voluntary method recommended by the European Commission, and the proposed Green Claims Directive has not become law.
This is general information, not legal advice. Check your own claims with a legal adviser.
You choose. The Nutrition tab opens a list of labelling markets, and the nutrition table, front-of-pack symbols, allergen list and Pro certificate all follow the market you pick. CHEF starts on the EU (or the USA if your browser is set to US English), and remembers your choice.
All markets shows the headline figures for every region side by side. On the Pro certificate you can also add comparison pages for other markets.
The dish is the same, but the rules are not. Countries use different reference values (for example the EU's 70 g of fat against the US Daily Value of 78 g), different rounding, and different definitions: US and Canadian carbohydrate includes fibre, the EU's does not; the EU declares salt, most other regions declare sodium. CHEF calculates each panel from the same ingredient data, applying each market's own rules.
The CIQUAL database does not record added sugars or trans fat, which several markets require. CHEF estimates them from the ingredients (for example sugar and honey you add, and the natural trans fat in dairy, beef and lamb). Estimated values are marked † on the label.
All labels are indicative, calculated from database values rather than laboratory analysis. Where a market's official text could not be checked, CHEF uses a stated stand-in and says so in the label's footnote. Check the current rules for your market before printing packaging.
Yes. In the Recipes panel, open Your recipes and choose Import recipes from a spreadsheet, or drop an Excel or CSV file onto the input bar. Use one row per ingredient with the dish name, ingredient, quantity, unit and servings (the dish name and servings only need to be on each dish's first row). Exports from recipe and costing software usually work as they are: CHEF recognises the columns by their headings, and you can correct them before matching. A template is available in the import window.
Quantities can be in grams, kilograms, millilitres, spoons, cans or a number of items, and are divided by the servings to give one serving. Each ingredient is matched to our database the same way as a pasted recipe, then you can check the matches dish by dish before saving. Imported recipes go to Your recipes and open in the Menu overview, where you can compare them and download the results as a CSV file.
Costs (optional): if your file has an ingredient cost column (the cost of each line) or a cost per serving, and a menu price, the Menu Overview shows each dish's cost per serving, menu price and gross profit (GP), with the menu's average GP and its kg CO₂e per £1 of gross profit. You can also type or change costs and prices directly in the Menu Overview. Enter prices without VAT for the usual GP figure.
Currencies and measures: the Menu Overview works in pounds, euros or US dollars. CHEF picks one from your region and from currency signs or codes in an imported file (such as “Cost (EUR)”), and you can change it in the Menu Overview. Column headings and kitchen units (such as EL, c. à s., cucharada, Zehen or gousses) can be in English, French, German, Spanish, Italian or Dutch. Our ingredient database is in English, so any ingredient that isn't found by name (another language, a spice blend or a house product) is passed to AI, which works out what it is: “Tomaten” becomes tomatoes, and a blend such as ras el hanout is split into its typical spices at the same weight. These are marked AI in the review so you can check them, and your own wording is kept for the label. Quantities can be metric or US/imperial: ounces, pounds, cups, fluid ounces, pints, quarts and gallons (US sizes for US browsers, imperial elsewhere) and US sticks of butter. Cups of dry ingredients such as flour, sugar, rice and oats are converted by their typical weight.
CHEF checks every ingredient in your recipe for the 14 allergens regulated in the UK and EU (Regulation 1169/2011, Annex II): cereals containing gluten, crustaceans, eggs, fish, peanuts, soya, milk, tree nuts, celery, mustard, sesame, sulphur dioxide/sulphites, lupin and molluscs. It reads the ingredient names, so “Parmesan cheese” is flagged for milk and “Dried pasta” for wheat. For gluten and tree nuts it names the cereal or nut (wheat, barley, almond…), and for fish and shellfish the species, as labels must.
The results appear in the Ingredients and allergens section under your recipe, with small tags against each ingredient:
Important: allergen information in CHEF is indicative. It cannot see supplier recipes, “may contain” warnings or cross-contact in your kitchen. Always confirm against supplier specifications and your own allergen controls before giving allergen information to customers. The food business remains responsible for it.
The Lite label follows the UK/EU approach: the ingredients are listed once, heaviest first by the weight used, with allergens emphasised in bold within the list, for example “Dried pasta (wheat), Parmesan cheese (milk)”. A short line tells people that allergens are shown in bold. UK Food Standards Agency guidance advises against repeating allergens in a separate “Contains” statement. Allergens you add by hand are not in any ingredient name, so they are shown as “Also contains”.
Where an ingredient is named in the dish name, its percentage is shown (for example “Beef mince (36%)” in a beef lasagne), as quantitative ingredient declaration (QUID) rules expect. Made products such as stocks or sauces are marked with an asterisk, as a reminder to add their own ingredients from the supplier label. You can rename any ingredient for the label with the tag field under it in the recipe builder. The Copy button copies the finished list for your own packaging, keeping the bold, or in CAPITALS where bold isn't kept.
The Pro certificate is a technical specification for buyers. It gives the ingredient list, ingredient weights and the allergen statement for the market you choose, in that market's own form: for example “Contains: Wheat, Milk” for the USA, the bold “Contains” summary for Australia and New Zealand, or the Japanese and Chinese wording with an English translation. Pork and alcohol are added when you have chosen to show them.
For pre-packed for direct sale (PPDS) food in the UK, Natasha's Law requires the name of the food and a full ingredient list with allergens emphasised. For dishes served in a restaurant, allergen information must be available to customers, but a full ingredient list is not required.
Each country has its own list of allergens that must be declared. CHEF works out each list from the 14 UK/EU allergens it detects, and shows the one for the market chosen on the Nutrition tab:
The USA has 9 major food allergens (FALCPA 2004, plus sesame from 1 January 2023 under the FASTER Act): milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans and sesame. Differences from the UK/EU list:
With the USA market chosen, CHEF shows a US-style “Contains:” line on the Nutrition tab, in the allergen section and on the Pro certificate. It names the fish or shellfish species and the type of tree nut (including pine nuts), and notes when ingredients such as wine or dried fruit may carry sulfites.
LCA (Life Cycle Assessment) quantifies a product’s environmental impacts across its entire life cycle, including stages like agriculture, transport, packaging, and storage. This comprehensive method accounts for every phase from raw materials to end-of-life.
For each stage, balances of materials, energy, and pollutant emissions are calculated and combined into environmental indicators. This results in 16 indicators per product, as recommended by the European Commission’s Product Environmental Footprint project (see above).
Disclaimer: Our calculations are based on scientific research and the best available data. Methodologies are continuously updated to reflect the most recent scientific understanding.